By Carmen Nobel Article
“Firms in the United States, Japan, and Germany tend to be managed especially well, while firms in Brazil, China, and India tend to be managed poorly. … over the past seven years, large teams of … analysts have interviewed managers at some 10,000 organizations in 20 countries, setting out to determine how and why management practices differ vastly in style and quality.
Best practices
The researchers used an evaluation tool … that broadly rated management practices in three areas: monitoring—how well managers keep track of what’s happening in a firm and make good use of that information;targets—how well organizations set appropriate goals and outcomes, and whether they take action if the two are inconsistent; and incentives—whether organizations promoted and rewarded employees based on performance and tried to keep the best performers from quitting. …
In the United States, India, and China, managerial use of incentives are much more common than the use of monitoring and target-setting, especially in the manufacturing field. In Japan, Sweden, and Germany, monitoring and target-setting far exceed the use of incentives.
But the differences surpassed international boundaries. … the researchers managed to discover certain ownership patterns that help to explain the dispersion. For instance, government-owned organizations tend to receive low management scores across all the sectors and countries in the study. “They are particularly weak at incentives,” the paper explains. “Promotion is more likely to be based on tenure (rather than performance), and persistent low-performers are much less likely to be retrained or moved.”
Family-owned businesses scored even lower—particularly those run by a firstborn son who inherited the role of CEO. Family-owned businesses that employed a non-related CEO scored much higher. “The finding there is not so much that family ownership per se is associated with lower scores, but rather family ownership when the selection of the CEO is not meritocratic,” Sadun says. “Especially in Europe, you have a lot of companies where the transmission of leadership is based on criteria completely unrelated to your ability to lead.”"